Nat for Nothing

by Maria Scrivan

In Maria Scrivan’s graphic novel Nat for Nothing, Natalie feels left out when her friends find school clubs that match their interests, while she struggles to discover an interest of her own. Through humorous school experiences and the challenges of friendship, Nat explores belonging, self-confidence, and the difference between finding an activity and proving her worth. Although listed here as a picture book, this title is a middle-grade graphic novel; use selected, teacher-previewed scenes with K–2 and longer selections or the complete book with grades 3–5.

Big Idea

Not knowing your interests yet does not mean you have nothing to offer. Trying new experiences and allowing yourself to be a beginner can help you discover what matters to you without measuring your worth against other people.

Discussion Questions

1.Why does seeing her friends find clubs make Nat question herself? What might she be assuming about their experiences?
2.How do Scrivan’s pictures help us understand feelings that Nat does not say aloud?
3.When do Nat’s comparisons with other people help her, and when do they make her situation harder?
4.What makes a club or group feel welcoming? How could Nat and her classmates help someone who has not found a place yet?
5.How does Nat’s story challenge the idea that you must already be good at something before you try it?

Lesson Plan

⏱ 45 minutes: 8 minutes reading, 7 minutes discussion, 5 minutes planning, 15 minutes creating, and 10 minutes sharing and revising📦 A copy of Nat for Nothing, teacher-selected pages for display, paper or comic-panel templates, pencils, erasers, crayons or markers, and sticky notes

Learning Goals

Explain Nat’s response to her friends’ club choices using evidence from words and illustrations.
Describe how panel sequence, dialogue, and silent images influence a graphic narrative’s pace.
Create a logically sequenced comic with a challenge, an attempt, and a believable change.
Identify supportive language that welcomes beginners and separates personal worth from performance.

Activity Steps

1.Read a teacher-selected sequence showing Nat’s uncertainty about clubs. Identify what happens, what Nat says, and what her expression or posture adds.
2.Discuss the difference between having no interests and not having discovered an interest yet. Brainstorm welcoming clubs that encourage curiosity rather than existing expertise.
3.Plan six panels: noticing others’ choices, feeling uncertain, receiving an invitation, trying an activity, reacting silently, and recognizing a small next step.
4.Draw and write the comic. Use several brief panels to move through action, then make the silent reaction panel visually prominent to invite a pause.
5.Exchange comics with a partner. Ask partners to identify where they read quickly, where they paused, and which words or pictures caused that change.
6.Revise one pacing choice and share the final panel. For K–2, use a three-panel beginning–middle–end version with drawing, dictation, or shared writing; for grades 3–5, add dialogue and a written explanation of one revision.

Standards Connections

ELA: CCSS RL.K.3–RL.2.3 — With grade-appropriate support, identify characters and major events and describe characters’ responses to challenges.
ELA: CCSS RL.3.7 — Explain how illustrations contribute to aspects of a story, including mood and character.
ELA: CCSS W.3.3–W.5.3 — Develop narratives using effective sequencing, dialogue, description, and details.
ELA: CCSS SL.K.1–SL.5.1 — Participate in collaborative conversations, listen to others, and build on their ideas.
SEL and Visual Arts: Develop self-awareness and relationship skills; create and revise visual narratives that communicate experiences and feelings.

Pace-Write-Read Study with Pace-Write It!

Nat for Nothing offers a useful pacing study because Maria Scrivan tells Nat’s story through both language and sequential art. Nat’s uncertainty about school clubs is not communicated only through statements about her feelings: readers also interpret expressions, posture, dialogue exchanges, and the movement from panel to panel. In Pace-Write-Read, students first notice how these choices shape their reading speed, then borrow a technique for their own writing, and finally read their work aloud or share it visually to test its effect. Center the study on a teacher-selected club-related sequence and a contrasting conversation or reflective moment. Ask students where the story seems to move quickly and where they spend extra time interpreting Nat’s feelings; emphasize that a short stretch of text can still invite a long emotional pause. Because this is a graphic novel rather than a picture book, teach panel transitions as well as page turns. With younger learners, model the reading order and work with a few panels; with older learners, examine how humor, friendship tension, and a moment of self-doubt can occupy the same sequence.

Element	How to notice or teach it in the novel
1. Pacing	Compare a club-related sequence with a quieter moment of Nat reacting to her situation. Ask which panel arrangements and amounts of dialogue make students move ahead or linger.
2. Plot	Trace how Nat’s difficulty finding a club creates a problem that leads to choices and new experiences. Distinguish the external question of choosing an activity from the internal question of feeling worthwhile.
3. Prosody	Read a conversation involving Nat aloud, using punctuation and facial expressions to guide phrasing. Try a different delivery and discuss how it changes the scene’s emotional pace.
4. Word	Study the word “nothing” in the title alongside Nat’s uncertainty about her interests. Invite students to explain why that word feels more absolute than “undecided” or “still exploring.”
5. Concept	Name the distinction between an activity someone enjoys and that person’s overall value. Ask how Nat’s club problem makes this abstract idea visible through everyday school experiences.
6. Voice & Worldview	Notice how Scrivan balances Nat’s genuine worries with humor. Discuss how the storytelling invites readers to understand Nat rather than dismiss her concerns.
7. Point of View	Track how closely readers follow Nat’s experiences and reactions. Rewrite a brief moment from another student’s perspective to explore what that student might know or misunderstand.
8. Setting & Place	Examine how the school setting brings Nat into contact with clubs, friends, and opportunities for comparison. Ask how the same uncertainty might feel different outside school.
9. Original Characters	Identify details that make Nat more specific than a generic worried student, including her expressions, responses, and relationships. Have students give their comic protagonist a distinctive reaction to being a beginner.
10. Dialogue	Compare what Nat says in a selected exchange with what her face communicates. Discuss how short back-and-forth speech can advance a scene while leaving feelings partly unstated.
11. Details	Look for small visual details that clarify a school activity or a character’s reaction. Ask which details readers need to understand Nat’s situation and which simply enrich the scene.
12. Descriptions	Scrivan can show a setting or emotion without stopping for a prose paragraph. Translate one panel into descriptive sentences, then discuss how the change affects reading speed.
13. Firsts	Use Nat’s search for an interest to discuss the vulnerability of trying something unfamiliar. In student comics, stretch the moment just before a first attempt into a separate panel.
14. Immediacy & Engagement	Ask how seeing Nat react directly to friends and school situations helps readers enter her problem. Begin a practice comic with a visible situation rather than a long explanation.
15. Story Scenes, Summaries & Structures	Identify a moment presented as a full exchange and compare it with a transition that moves readers ahead. Discuss which parts of Nat’s experience deserve a scene because something emotionally important changes.
16. Tension / Suspense / Surprise	Follow the uncertainty surrounding Nat’s search for a place to belong. Pause before a response or outcome and ask what readers hope will happen and what they worry might happen.
17. Flashback, Flash-Forward, Cliffhanger	Check the selected pages for these devices rather than assuming all three appear. If absent, have students imagine how adding a memory, a future glimpse, or an unresolved stopping point would change Nat’s scene.
18. Page Turns and Chapter Breaks	Inspect what information is withheld at an actual page turn or section boundary. Ask whether the stopping point builds curiosity about Nat’s next choice, extends a joke, or gives an emotion room to settle.
19. Pace & Creativity	Redraw the same Nat-inspired club encounter in three panels and then six. Compare how the extra beats create room for hesitation, humor, or observation.
20. Play	Invite students to approach Nat’s club dilemma playfully by inventing a club where mistakes are expected. Use imaginative possibilities to open the story rather than solve it through instant talent.
21. Performance	Perform a selected exchange using readers for speech balloons and an actor for Nat’s expressions. Include the time needed to look or react so the pictures are not lost in the performance.
22. Personality	Compare Nat’s response to a club opportunity with another character’s response. Discuss how different personalities create different rhythms of speaking, deciding, and acting.
23. Humor	Find a sequence students consider funny and identify the setup and payoff. Ask whether a reaction, contrast, or delay makes the humor work without minimizing Nat’s feelings.
24. Pause	Look for a panel where a facial expression carries more meaning than speech. Practice allowing that image a beat of silence during a shared reading.
25. Poetry / Poetic Devices	Although this is not a verse narrative, examine the sound play of “Nat” and “Nothing” in the title. Invite students to test alliteration or a repeated phrase in their own comic without assuming such devices occur throughout the book.
26. Repetition	Track recurring references to clubs, interests, and belonging. Discuss how returning to the same concern can reveal a change in Nat’s understanding rather than simply repeat information.
27. Rhythm	Read a panel sequence as a pattern of speech, action, and reaction. Have students tap once per panel, then notice where actual reading requires a longer or shorter beat.
28. Punctuation	Inspect punctuation in Nat’s speech balloons and connect it to tone and phrasing. Rewrite a short student-created line with different punctuation to test its effect.
29. Questions	Separate questions characters actually ask from questions readers infer, such as where Nat might belong. Discuss how an unanswered question encourages continued reading.
30. Compare-Contrast	Contrast Nat’s uncertainty with her friends’ apparent confidence about their club choices. Ask whether looking confident necessarily means someone feels confident.
31. Objects	Select an object actually pictured in a club-related scene and explain how it helps identify the activity or situation. In student comics, use one recognizable object to establish a club quickly.
32. Threes	Check whether a selected sequence groups actions or reactions into three beats; do not assume a rule-of-three pattern. Then try a three-beat version of a club invitation: offer, hesitation, response.
33. Lists	Turn the clubs or interests mentioned in the pages read into a class list. Compare how quickly a list communicates possibilities with how slowly a scene explores Nat’s response to one possibility.
34. White Space & Negative Space	Examine the gaps between panels and the uncluttered space around figures or words. Ask how readers supply movement and elapsed time between images, and distinguish that inference from a deliberate emotional pause.
35. Art & Graphics	Study Scrivan’s cartoon expressions, body language, and visual sequencing. Cover the words briefly and ask what students can still infer about Nat, then restore the text to check their interpretations.
36. Interactives & Gamification	Treat interactivity as a classroom extension, not a built-in feature of the novel. Give pairs a pacing hunt: locate a quick exchange, an expressive reaction, and a transition, explaining each choice without racing.
37. Placement	Follow the placement of balloons and panels to establish reading order in a selected page. Discuss how moving a reaction before or after a line could change the timing of a Nat-centered scene.
38. Form	Explain how the graphic-novel form shares storytelling between words and images. Compare a short prose retelling of Nat’s club problem with the original panels to identify what each form makes immediate.
39. Dummy	Create a rough folded-paper dummy of a Nat-inspired club story before making finished art. Move the invitation, attempt, and reaction onto different pages to test where a page turn is most effective.
40. Passion	Connect Nat’s uncertainty to the idea that interests may grow through exploration rather than arrive fully formed. Invite students to end with something their character wants to try again, not a declaration of exceptional talent.

Pace-Write It!

20-minute Pace-Write-It! task — “One Invitation, Two Speeds.” Minutes 0–4: Revisit a short, teacher-selected sequence about Nat’s uncertainty over clubs; identify one place readers move quickly and one place they study her reaction. Minutes 4–7: Students invent a welcoming club and plan a fictional beginner’s response to an invitation, connecting the character’s uncertainty to Nat’s experience. Minutes 7–13: Draw two versions of the same encounter: a quick three-panel version and a slower five-panel version that adds hesitation and a silent reaction. Minutes 13–17: Partners read both versions, allowing time to view each image, and explain which moment feels longer and why. Minutes 17–20: Students revise one panel or speech balloon and complete the reflection, “I slowed down ___ so readers could understand ___.” K–2 students may draw and dictate; grades 3–5 should explain how an added beat changes the reader’s understanding without changing the main event.

Classroom Activities

A Club for the Curious

Students create a six-panel comic about a fictional student who, like Nat, feels unsure about choosing a school club. They invent a welcoming club, show the student trying something unfamiliar, and use panel size, dialogue, and a silent reaction panel to control how quickly readers experience the moment. The ending emphasizes a small discovery rather than instant mastery.

A Club for the Curious

Create a free account to reveal this guide

Your free account includes one complete guide download — the full teacher’s guide, discussion questions, classroom activities, and the Pace-Write-Read writing workshop.

Create Free Account Sign in

Discussion questions PWR workshop PDF download